| Peoria Rivermen | Riverman | 11/2/2001 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Don Biggs | 12/8/2001 | 3000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | John Brophy | 1/25/2002 | |
| Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | Wooly | 3/30/2002 | 2000 |
| Florida Everblades | Swampee | 10/25/2002 | 3000 |
| Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | Wooly (Santa) | 12/18/2002 | |
| Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | Wooly (Football) | 1/26/2003 | 2500 |
| Columbus Cottonmouths | Craig Stahl | 1/31/2003 | 1000 |
| Peoria Rivermen | Tony Twist | 1/31/2003 | |
| Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | Wooly (Cupid) | 2/14/2003 | 2500 |
| Charlotte Checkers | Chubby | 2/15/2003 | |
| Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | Wooly (Lincoln) | 2/19/2003 | 2500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Joe Mullen | 2/21/2003 | 2000 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Dave Seitz | 2/22/2003 | 2500 |
| Trenton Titans | Rivet | 2/28/2003 | 1000 |
| Greensboro Generals | Kevin Weekes | 2/28/2003 | 1000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Iceburgh | 3/9/2003 | |
| Augusta Lynx | Louie | 3/15/2003 | 2000 |
| Dayton Bombers | Trevor Ettinger | 3/28/2003 | 2000 |
| Peoria Rivermen | Kelly Chase | 3/30/2003 | |
| Bakersfield Condors | Jason Ralph | 10/18/2003 | 2000 |
| Long Beach Ice Dogs | Spike | 11/15/2003 | 2500 |
| Fresno Falcons | Glen Gulutzan | 12/14/2003 | 2000 |
| Las Vegas Wranglers | Duke | 1/9/2004 | 1500 |
| Peoria Rivermen | Trevor Baker | 1/17/2004 | 3000 |
| Fresno Falcons | Jason Weaver | 1/30/2004 | 2500 |
| Peoria Rivermen | Tyler Rennette | 2/14/2004 | 2500 |
| Idaho Steelheads | Scott Burt | 2/25/2004 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Wesbanco Buck | 2/28/2004 | |
| Florida Everblades | Reggie Berg | 3/13/2004 | 1000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Quinn Fair | 3/13/2004 | 2000 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Brett Marietti | 3/13/2004 | 2500 |
| Long Beach Ice Dogs | Spike | 3/20/2004 | 2500 |
| Johnstown Chiefs | Jeff Sullivan | 3/28/2004 | 2000 |
| Las Vegas Wranglers | George W. Bush | 11/2/2004 | 1000 |
| Las Vegas Wranglers | John Kerry | 11/2/2004 | 1000 |
| Long Beach Ice Dogs | Spike | 11/6/2004 | |
| Louisiana IceGators | Alphonse | 11/20/2004 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Pat Bingham | 12/18/2004 | |
| Florida Everblades | Rob Zepp | 1/22/2005 | 3000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Connor James | 1/28/2005 | 2000 |
| Peoria Rivermen | Bulldozer | 1/29/2005 | |
| Charlotte Checkers | Derek Wilkinson | 2/5/2005 | 2000 |
| Idaho Steelheads | Lance Galbraith | 3/5/2005 | |
| Fresno Falcons | John Wroblewski | 3/12/2005 | 2500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Kirk Daubenspeck | 3/12/2005 | |
| Gwinnett Gladiators | Cam Brown | 3/13/2005 | 1000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Mario Lemieux | 3/19/2005 | |
| Reading Royals | Ryan Flinn | 4/7/2005 | |
| Reading Royals | Simon Tremblay | 12/2/2005 | 2000 |
| Trenton Titans | Clash | 12/30/2005 | 1000 |
| Reading Royals | Brian McCullough | 1/20/2006 | 2000 |
| Dayton Bombers | Bucky | 2/17/2006 | |
| Reading Royals | Cody Rudkowsky | 2/24/2006 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Terry Virtue | 2/25/2006 | 2500 |
| Florida Everblades | Brandon Coalter | 2/28/2006 | 2500 |
| Reading Royals | Barry Brust | 3/4/2006 | 2000 |
| Gwinnett Gladiators | Runaway Bride | 3/5/2006 | 1000 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Trevor Johnson | 3/11/2006 | |
| Fresno Falcons | Fraser Clair | 3/18/2006 | 2000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Kevin St. Jacques | 3/18/2006 | |
| Charlotte Checkers | Steve MacIntyre | 3/30/2006 | 2000 |
| Reading Royals | Reagan Rome | 4/7/2006 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Glen Patrick | 11/25/2006 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Gilbert Dionne | 12/2/2006 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Bo Cheesman | 12/16/2006 | 2500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Mike Lalonde | 12/30/2006 | 1000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Spike | 1/13/2007 | |
| Trenton Titans | Rivet | 1/26/2007 | |
| Bakersfield Condors | Todd Griffith | 2/9/2007 | 2000 |
| Stockton Thunder | Devan Dubnyk | 2/11/2007 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Curtiss Patrick | 2/24/2007 | 2500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Cail MacLean | 3/10/2007 | 2500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Adam Huxley | 3/10/2007 | 1000 |
| Florida Everblades | Ernie Hartlieb | 3/14/2007 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Andy Franck | 3/17/2007 | |
| Columbia Inferno | Blaze | 3/30/2007 | 1000 |
| Charlotte Checkers | Dusty Jamieson | 3/31/2007 | 2000 |
| Fresno Falcons | Luke Curtin | 4/6/2007 | 2000 |
| Trenton Titans | Scott Bertoli | 4/7/2007 | |
| Bakersfield Condors | Colonel Claw'd | 10/20/2007 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Wesbanco Buck | 11/24/2007 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Santa Claus | 12/22/2007 | |
| Stockton Thunder | Cam Ellsworth | 12/28/2007 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Joe Zelek | 1/12/2008 | |
| Stockton Thunder | Jesse Bennefield | 2/2/2008 | 1000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 2/9/2008 | 1500 |
| Trenton Devils | Scorch | 2/16/2008 | 2000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Yutaka Fukufuji | 2/23/2008 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Sean Collins | 2/23/2008 | |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Nate Kiser | 3/15/2008 | 2500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Brian Lee | 3/15/2008 | 1000 |
| Charlotte Checkers | Chubby | 3/21/2008 | 2000 |
| Columbia Inferno | Brad Ralph | 3/22/2008 | 1200 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Moondog | 3/22/2008 | 2500 |
| Florida Everblades | Steve Saviano | 3/26/2008 | 2500 |
| Fresno Falcons | Matt O'Dette | 3/29/2008 | 2000 |
| Reading Royals | Matt Herneisen | 4/4/2008 | 2500 |
| Reading Royals | Greg Hogeboom | 11/16/2008 | 1500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Darren Schwartz | 11/29/2008 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | David Desharnais | 12/13/2008 | 3000 |
| Fresno Falcons | Freddie Falcon | 12/18/2008 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Moondog | 12/27/2008 | |
| Stockton Thunder | Thor | 12/27/2008 | 1000 |
| Reading Royals | David Masse | 1/17/2009 | 1500 |
| Ontario Reign | Blaze | 1/17/2009 | 5000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Mark Derlago | 1/23/2009 | 2000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Barack Obama | 1/24/2009 | 3000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Reno Saccoccia | 1/31/2009 | |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Travis Morin | 2/7/2009 | 2500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Cory Urquhart | 2/14/2009 | 1000 |
| Ontario Reign | Dark Knight | 2/14/2009 | 3000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 2/21/2009 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Spike | 2/28/2009 | |
| Reading Royals | TJ Kemp | 3/6/2009 | 1500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Garet Hunt | 3/7/2009 | |
| Bakersfield Condors | Matt Caruana | 3/20/2009 | 2000 |
| Ontario Reign | Karl Taylor | 3/21/2009 | 3500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | B.E. Taylor | 3/21/2009 | 2500 |
| Reading Royals | Jon Francisco | 3/25/2009 | 1500 |
| Charlotte Checkers | Darryl Noren | 3/27/2009 | |
| Florida Everblades | Brad Herauf | 4/3/2009 | 2500 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Baby Cal | 10/17/2009 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | George Kellas | 11/28/2009 | 2500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Spike | 12/5/2009 | |
| Stockton Thunder | Thor | 12/27/2009 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Bill Cunningham | 1/29/2010 | 2500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Doug Sauter | 1/30/2010 | 2500 |
| Reading Royals | Jonathan Quick | 1/31/2010 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Snowbird | 2/6/2010 | 1500 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 2/26/2010 | 2500 |
| Trenton Devils | Jeff Frazee | 2/27/2010 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | O.V. McBear | 3/6/2010 | |
| Trenton Devils | Pierre-Luc Letourneau-Leblond | 3/13/2010 | |
| Bakersfield Condors | Andrew Ianiero | 3/19/2010 | 2000 |
| Ontario Reign | Jeff Zatkoff | 11/6/2010 | 3000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Santa Claus | 12/10/2010 | 2500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Dave Hanson | 12/11/2010 | 2500 |
| Ontario Reign | Bud Holloway | 1/8/2011 | 3000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 1/14/2011 | 2500 |
| Ontario Reign | Luc Robitaille | 2/12/2011 | 3000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Bob Herzog | 2/25/2011 | 2500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Brad Paisley | 3/4/2011 | 2500 |
| Trenton Devils | Tony Zancanaro | 3/11/2011 | 2000 |
| Stockton Thunder | Jason Morgan | 12/2/2011 | 1500 |
| Colorado Eagles | Kyle Jones | 12/17/2011 | 2500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Oliver Roy | 1/20/2012 | 1500 |
| Idaho Steelheads | Marty Flichel | 1/27/2012 | |
| Colorado Eagles | Adam Chorneyko | 1/28/2012 | |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Matt Scherer | 2/11/2012 | 1000 |
| Ontario Reign | David Walker | 2/11/2012 | 3000 |
| Stockton Thunder | Kevin Baker | 2/17/2012 | 1500 |
| Ontario Reign | Jon Francisco | 2/18/2012 | 3000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Hans Benson | 2/24/2012 | 2000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 2/24/2012 | 2500 |
| Ontario Reign | Shawn Germain | 3/3/2012 | 3000 |
| Colorado Eagles | Kyle Peto | 3/28/2012 | |
| Stockton Thunder | Thor | 12/29/2012 | 1000 |
| Fort Wayne Komets | Kaleigh Schrock | 1/4/2013 | 1000 |
| Greenville Road Warriors | TJ Reynolds | 1/5/2013 | 1500 |
| Ontario Reign | Jordan Nolan | 1/5/2013 | 3000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Spike | 1/6/2013 | 2000 |
| Gwinnett Gladiators | Andy Brandt | 1/12/2013 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Barack Obama | 1/25/2013 | 2500 |
| Idaho Steelheads | Blue | 2/8/2013 | 1000 |
| Colorado Eagles | Michael Forney | 2/23/2013 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Puck Chop | 3/2/2013 | 2500 |
| Ontario Reign | Dwight King | 3/2/2013 | 3000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Scott Greenham & Brian Stewart | 3/9/2013 | 2000 |
| Colorado Eagles | Chad Costello | 3/23/2013 | 2500 |
| Evansville IceMen | Josh Beaulieu | 11/16/2013 | 1000 |
| San Francisco Bulls | Pat Curcio | 11/27/2013 | 1000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Cody Lampl | 11/29/2013 | 2000 |
| Reading Royals | Yannick Tifu | 12/7/2013 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Tomas Vokoun | 12/21/2013 | 2500 |
| Toledo Walleye | Nick Vitucci | 1/3/2014 | 2000 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Darius Rucker | 1/4/2014 | 2000 |
| Kalamazoo Wings | Nick Bootland | 1/4/2014 | 3000 |
| San Francisco Bulls | Dean Ouellet | 1/15/2014 | 1000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Josh Hutcherson | 1/17/2014 | 2500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Clark Donatelli | 2/15/2014 | 2500 |
| Greenville Road Warriors | Dean Stork | 2/15/2014 | 1500 |
| Orlando Solar Bears | Shades | 2/15/2014 | 3000 |
| Colorado Eagles | Adam Brown | 2/22/2014 | 2500 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | David MacDonald | 3/8/2014 | 2500 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Dancin Granny | 3/15/2014 | 2000 |
| Stockton Thunder | Thor | 3/22/2014 | 1000 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Joel Broda | 4/5/2014 | 2000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Paul Bissonnette | 4/5/2014 | 2500 |
| Colorado Eagles | Kyle Ostrow | 4/12/2014 | |
| Wheeling Nailers | Patrick McGrath | 12/6/2014 | 2500 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Cheeze | 12/12/2014 | 1500 |
| Colorado Eagles | AJ Hau | 12/13/2014 | 2500 |
| Reading Royals | Jack Gulati | 12/27/2014 | 1500 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Mac | 1/9/2015 | 1500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Patrick Gaul | 1/17/2015 | 1000 |
| Colorado Eagles | Greg Gardner | 2/6/2015 | 2500 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Richard Matvichuk | 2/6/2015 | 1500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Ryan Constant | 2/21/2015 | 500 |
| Bakersfield Condors | Kellen Jones | 2/28/2015 | 2000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 3/13/2015 | 2500 |
| Stockton Thunder | Peter Sivak | 3/14/2015 | 500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Shep Rose | 3/20/2015 | 1000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Kyle Rogers | 4/4/2015 | 2000 |
| Indy Fuel | Nitro | 4/8/2015 | 2500 |
| Colorado Eagles | Trent Daavettila | 4/11/2015 | 2500 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Lamar Hunt Jr. | 11/28/2015 | 1500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Cool Ray | 12/12/2015 | 1000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Petr Mrazek | 1/15/2016 | 1500 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Mac | 1/22/2016 | 1500 |
| Colorado Eagles | Collin Bowman | 1/30/2016 | 2500 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Andrew Courtney | 2/12/2016 | 1500 |
| Toledo Walleye | Petr Mrazek | 2/21/2016 | 1500 |
| Manchester Monarchs | Max | 3/12/2016 | 4000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Petr Mrazek | 3/26/2016 | 1500 |
| Indy Fuel | Scott Hillman | 4/8/2016 | 1000 |
| Quad City Mallards | Darren McMillan | 4/9/2016 | 1000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Jeff Lerg | 11/5/2016 | 1500 |
| Greenville Swamp Rabbits | Stomper | 11/12/2016 | 1000 |
| Missouri Mavericks | John-Scott Dickson | 11/12/2016 | 1500 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Spike | 11/26/2016 | 2500 |
| Reading Royals | Riley Gill | 12/28/2016 | 2500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Trevor Gillies | 12/31/2016 | |
| Colorado Eagles | Darryl Bootland | 1/7/2017 | 2500 |
| Reading Royals | Olivier Labell | 1/16/2017 | 2500 |
| Manchester Monarchs | Tyler Toffoli | 1/21/2017 | 4000 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Cheeze | 1/27/2017 | 1500 |
| Missouri Mavericks | Mac | 2/3/2017 | 1500 |
| Toledo Walleye | AJ Jenks | 2/4/2017 | 2000 |
| Reading Royals | Yannick Tifu | 2/11/2017 | 2500 |
| Wichita Thunder | Barry Sanders | 2/17/2017 | 1000 |
| Reading Royals | Ryan Cruthers | 3/4/2017 | 2500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Joe Devin | 3/11/2017 | 2000 |
| Rapid City Rush | Riley Weselowski | 3/31/2017 | 500 |
| Indy Fuel | Chris DeSousa | 4/8/2017 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 11/17/2017 | 3000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Evan Rankin | 11/18/2017 | 2000 |
| Worcester Railers | Trax | 12/2/2017 | 3000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Alden Hirschfeld | 1/5/2018 | |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Marcus Perrier | 1/6/2018 | 2000 |
| Kalamazoo Wings | Darren Archibald | 1/27/2018 | 1000 |
| Worcester Railers | Ashton Rome | 2/3/2018 | 3000 |
| Kansas City Mavericks | Mac | 2/3/2018 | 1500 |
| Colorado Eagles | Matt Garbowsky | 2/9/2018 | |
| Kalamazoo Wings | Slappy | 2/17/2018 | |
| Wichita Thunder | Nico Hernandez | 3/2/2018 | 1000 |
| Worcester Railers | Captain America | 3/3/2018 | 3000 |
| Wheeling Nailers | Carter Rowney | 3/10/2018 | 2500 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Jay Kruz | 3/16/2018 | 3000 |
| Wichita Thunder | Ron Baker | 3/30/2018 | 1000 |
| Indy Fuel | Nitro | 4/7/2018 | 1200 |
| Toledo Walleye | Mike Eruzione | 11/17/2018 | 2000 |
| Indy Fuel | Zach Miskovic | 12/21/2018 | 1200 |
| Wichita Thunder | Dyson Stevenson | 1/12/2019 | 1000 |
| Worcester Railers | Mitch Gillam | 1/12/2019 | |
| Allen Americans | Biscuit | 1/30/2019 | 1000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Genius of Water Fountain | 2/1/2019 | 3000 |
| Kansas City Mavericks | Mac | 2/2/2019 | 1500 |
| Wichita Thunder | Fred VanVleet | 2/2/2019 | 1000 |
| Kalamazoo Wings | Kevin Evans | 3/1/2019 | 1000 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Parker Milner | 3/2/2019 | 2000 |
| Jacksonville IceMen | Fang | 3/9/2019 | 3000 |
| Worcester Railers | Trax | 3/16/2019 | 3000 |
| Kalamazoo Wings | Tyler Willis & Kory Karlander | 3/23/2019 | 1000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Shane Berschbach | 3/29/2019 | 2000 |
| Allen Americans | Steve Martinson | 3/29/2019 | 1500 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Lt. Bob Beres | 3/30/2019 | 2000 |
| Indy Fuel | Doug Christiansen | 10/25/2019 | 2500 |
| Atlanta Gladiators | Sean Bonar | 11/3/2019 | 2500 |
| Kansas City Mavericks | Mac & Mave | 11/8/2019 | 1500 |
| Toledo Walleye | Bryan Moore | 11/9/2019 | 1000 |
| Rapid City Rush | Nugget | 1/11/2020 | 1000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Pat Nagle | 1/24/2020 | 1000 |
| Kansas City Mavericks | Mac | 2/1/2020 | 1500 |
| Kalamazoo Wings | Joel Martin | 2/21/2020 | 1000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Justin Vaive | 2/28/2020 | 3000 |
| Jacksonville IceMen | Jason Christie | 3/7/2020 | 3000 |
| Florida Everblades | Swampee & Waste Pro Man | 3/27/2021 | 1000 |
| Indy Fuel | Jim Hallett | 5/29/2021 | 1000 |
| South Carolina Stingrays | Andrew Cherniwchan | 11/7/2021 | 1500 |
| Atlanta Gladiators | Generic Goaltender | 11/23/2021 | 1000 |
| Maine Mariners | Beacon | 1/8/2022 | 1000 |
| Reading Royals | Slapshot | 1/8/2022 | 2000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Josh Kestner | 1/21/2022 | 1500 |
| Adirondack Thunder | Gunnar | 1/29/2022 | 1000 |
| Worcester Railers | Trax | 2/5/2022 | 2000 |
| Kansas City Mavericks | Retro Player | 2/18/2022 | 2000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Thor | 2/25/2022 | |
| Reading Royals | Frank DiChiara | 3/5/2022 | |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Jason Payne | 3/11/2022 | 3000 |
| Reading Royals | Kirill Ustimenki | 3/18/2022 | 2000 |
| Toledo Walleye | Billy Christopoulos | 3/25/2022 | 1500 |
| Reading Royals | Philipp Grubauer | 3/26/2022 | 2000 |
| Cincinnati Cyclones | Twister | 4/1/2022 | 3000 |
| Indy Fuel | Keoni Texeira | 4/16/2022 | 1500 |